In 1998 I finished the 16th grade and moved thousands of miles from Madison. There was widespread concern that Madison would not survive this unscathed, and I’m sorry to say that the downslide of Madison has begun. The New York Times reports that Mayor Dave Cieslewicz and members of the Madison Common Council are pushing a plan to close several downtown bars and deny liquor licenses to new restaurants, to cut down on noise and crime.
In Madison, two Common Council members, convinced that much of what ails downtown can be traced to the proliferation of bars and restaurants known more for drinking than dining, introduced a plan intended to reduce the number of such establishments, and to restrict the approval of new liquor licenses.
The plan, which has the support of Mayor Cieslewicz (pronounced chess-LEV-ich), is preliminary and does not detail, for example, how many or which places may be closed. A final plan is expected to be ready for a Council vote in the spring.
That area of nearly one square mile — between Lake Mendota, Lake Monona and Blair and Lake Streets — has 120 places that serve only or mostly alcohol. They have a capacity of more than 11,000 people, city officials said.
The proposal has its critics, many of whom call it nothing less than modern-day Prohibition, and an assault on personal freedom and the free market that flies in the face of Madison’s traditional liberalism and Wisconsin’s entrenched drinking culture.
First off, one kudo to the Times for associating Wisconsin with something
other than its entrenched cheese-eating culture. A second kudo for recognizing this as an
assault on liberalism. Sure, alcohol
use encourages noise, vandalism, drunk driving, violence, unsafe sex, sexual assault, theft, public urination, unwanted forearm tattoos, and most
troublingly, hangovers. But to notice all that is to look at the Miller Lite bottle as half empty, or perhaps containing a floating cigarette butt. What about all the positive…well…the real point is that when we are not allowed in a free country to drink to our liver’s content, the terrorists win. The progressive way is to tax the bejeezus out of our sins, not ban them.
Why, you may well ask, is this happening now? After all, downtown Madison was not the quietest neighborhood when I lived there either, but no one formed a Beerstapo. Part of it is that the legendary Paul Soglin, UW student, Vietnam War-era activist and mayor of Madison by age 28, the person most responsible for downtown Madison’s revitalization, was narrowly defeated by this Dave Crossantwich character in the 2003 mayoral election. If only I’d been there, I tell myself, maybe things would have turned out differently. My civically responsible habit of loudly informing others as to the validity of their political opinions could have won Soglin…well, one more vote, at least if I made it to the polls on time. But still.
The other problem is more insidious. After years of building a reputation as a progressive community with a strong economy and high standard of living, Madison is now being invaded by…retired hippies! Not the tolerable ‘It takes all kinds, man’ sort, but the ‘Don’t you dare interrupt my nap time, because we old people vote’ ones.
But the arrival of so many newcomers has produced a culture clash.
Stefanie Moritz, a retired librarian, moved with her husband from Phoenix into a downtown condominium about three years ago, drawn by pedestrian-friendly streets, a university job for her husband and the community’s progressive politics.
“We decided that we definitely wanted to live downtown, so we could get rid of one of our cars, my husband could walk to work and we could enjoy the downtown experience,” Ms. Moritz said. “The reality is a little bit different.”
She said she quickly grew irritated at being awakened at 2:30 a.m., when the noisy bar crowd usually begins to make its way home, dropping empty beer cans and other trash along the way. One morning she woke to find that garbage had been torched and the flames had charred a tree.
“I want to live downtown, but I also want a decent quality of life,” Ms. Moritz said. “And I feel that that is being denied by the present level of alcohol use.”
You move to a major college town, park your ass at the nerve center, and don’t much care for it. That’s fine, but then leave it alone. You don’t see me moving to Phoenix and bitching about the trailer park sprawl, do you? How the hell can someone call themselves progressive, then expect different places and cultures to conform to their expectations? Take your gentrification and shove it up your card catalog.
I wish everyone living in Madison could spend some time in Westwood, near UCLA, to see what happens when the puritans seize control. Rather than Madison’s glorious 120 downtown bars, Westwood has but two mediocre bars. According to longtime residents, Westwood thrived in the 1980s, blocking off streets for pedestrians, but the noise levels led the community council to crack down, even following Utah’s lead by banning dancing. Now it has very little nightlife, despite being adjacent to a major university.
So please, Madisonians, vote Mayor Cissywedge and the rest of these knuckleheads out. Today it’s a crackdown on alcohol, tomorrow it’s a 12 pm curfew, and early next week sometime, Tuesday perhaps, a strip mall of alternating Applebees and Jamba Juices. Don’t let it come to that.


















